Forever One Moissanite by Charles & Colvard: What Real Customers Are Saying

Moissanite has rapidly emerged as a compelling alternative to traditional diamonds, captivating many with its exceptional brilliance and attractive price point. In the world of Moissanite, one name stands out as a pioneer and leader: Charles & Colvard.

Their premium offering, Forever One Moissanite, is often hailed as the closest lab-grown gem to colorless perfection. But beyond the marketing and the technical specifications, what do real customers actually think about their Forever One Moissanite?

Choosing a significant piece of jewelry, whether it’s an engagement ring, a special gift, or a personal indulgence, is a deeply personal journey. You want to know that the gem you select will live up to its promises. That’s why I’ve dug into the experiences of people who have purchased and worn Forever One Moissanite.

My goal here is to go beyond the polished product descriptions and synthesize the authentic feedback shared by real customers across various platforms, from dedicated forums like Reddit to direct product reviews. As an affiliate with Charles & Colvard, I have a thorough understanding of their brand and process, but this review is specifically focused on bringing you the unbiased insights derived directly from customer experiences.

For a more general overview of the company itself, you can also read my in-depth Charles & Colvard review In this post, we’ll look at what customers report about Forever One’s sparkle, how it holds up over time, whether they feel it’s worth the price, and their experiences with the company’s service and warranty. Let’s dive into what real wearers have to say.

Understanding Forever One Moissanite: What It Is and Why It’s Premium

Before we dive into what customers are saying, it helps to have a clear picture of what Forever One Moissanite is and its place in the gemstone world. Unlike diamonds, which formed deep within the Earth, natural moissanite is an incredibly rare mineral, first discovered in a meteorite crater in 1893 by French scientist Dr. Henri Moissan.

Its natural occurrence is so scarce that virtually all moissanite used in jewelry today is created in controlled laboratory environments.

The Journey of Moissanite

The process of growing single crystals of silicon carbide (the material moissanite is made of) in a lab was first developed in the late 20th century. Charles & Colvard was at the forefront of this innovation, pioneering the methods to produce gem-quality moissanite crystals large enough to be cut into stones for jewelry.

Their early lab-grown moissanite, known as “Classic” and later “Brilliant,” introduced the world to the gem’s exceptional fire and brilliance, but often exhibited subtle warm tints, sometimes described as yellowish or grayish undertones, which were inherent to the early growth process.

Charles & Colvard’s Innovation

Driven by a desire to create a moissanite that was as close to colorless as possible, Charles & Colvard invested heavily in research and development. This led to the creation of their Forever Brilliant grade, which significantly reduced the warmer hues found in Classic. But the true breakthrough came with Forever One.

Launched as their premier line, Forever One represented Charles & Colvard’s ability to consistently produce moissanite crystals that yield gems in the coveted near-colorless (G-H-I equivalent) and, more importantly, the truly colorless (D-E-F equivalent) ranges on the diamond color grading scale.

Forever One: Aiming for Colorless

Forever One is Charles & Colvard’s promise of their finest quality, most visually stunning moissanite. According to Charles & Colvard, their Forever One gems are graded in the D-E-F (colorless) or G-H-I (near-colorless) ranges, representing a significant leap from earlier moissanite products that typically fell into the J-K or warmer ranges.

This focus on achieving colorless grades as highlighted on the Charles & Colvard Forever One moissanite collection was a direct response to consumer demand for a moissanite that could truly compete with the appearance of high-quality, colorless diamonds.

When considering the array of options available, Charles & Colvard, particularly with their Forever One line, is often cited among discussions of the best moissanite brand, largely due to this commitment to producing near-colorless to colorless stones.

The Scientific Sparkle: Forever One’s Properties

Beyond its origin story, the true magic of Forever One Moissanite lies in its remarkable physical and optical properties. These aren’t just technical specifications; they are the scientific reasons behind its stunning appearance and why it performs the way it does in jewelry, directly influencing the experiences customers report.

Beyond Hardness: The Mohs Score

Moissanite is composed of Silicon Carbide (SiC), a compound with incredibly strong bonds between silicon and carbon atoms. This fundamental structure gives Moissanite its impressive durability. On the Mohs scale of hardness, which measures a mineral’s resistance to scratching, Moissanite scores a remarkable 9.25.

To put that into perspective, this makes it harder than sapphire and ruby (both 9) and significantly harder than most other gemstones used in jewelry. While not quite matching the diamond’s perfect 10, a 9.25 rating means Forever One Moissanite is exceptionally resistant to scratching and abrasion from everyday wear, ensuring it maintains its polished surface and sparkle over time.

The Science of Intense Sparkle (Dispersion & Refraction)

What truly sets Moissanite apart visually are its optical properties, particularly its interaction with light. Like diamonds, Moissanite has a high refractive index (RI), meaning it bends light significantly, contributing to brilliance.

However, Moissanite has a notably higher dispersion rate than diamond. Dispersion is the ability of a gemstone to split white light into its spectral colors – essentially, the intensity of the “rainbow flashes” or “fire” you see. Because Moissanite’s dispersion is higher, it typically exhibits more fiery, rainbow sparkle than a diamond of comparable size and cut. This is a key visual difference that many customers notice and often highly praise.

Furthermore, Moissanite is doubly refractive, meaning light splits into two rays as it passes through, although this double refraction is usually not apparent to the naked eye, especially in smaller stones or certain cuts.

How Properties Influence Appearance

These inherent properties directly translate into the Forever One Moissanite’s visual characteristics that resonate with customers. The high Mohs hardness ensures the stone remains bright and unscratched with daily wear, maintaining its “like new” look.

The high dispersion means Forever One delivers a powerful light show, often described by wearers as producing vibrant rainbow flashes, particularly under direct light sources. Understanding these scientific fundamentals helps explain why customers frequently comment on the exceptional sparkle and enduring beauty of their Forever One pieces.

Much like evaluating diamonds using the 4 Cs, understanding the core properties of Moissanite, as part of the broader 4Cs of Moissanite framework (which adapts color and clarity standards), provides crucial context for its performance and appeal.

Forever One Moissanite: What Real Customers Actually Think

Stepping away from the laboratory specs and marketing descriptions, the most valuable insights often come from the people who have actually purchased, worn, and lived with their jewelry.

To provide an authentic look at Charles & Colvard’s Forever One Moissanite, I’ve analyzed numerous customer accounts, digging through reviews on their site, exploring discussions on forums like Reddit, such as this thread on r/Moissanite, and synthesizing feedback from various online platforms.

What emerges is a picture of a gemstone that largely lives up to its promise, with some nuances that potential buyers should be aware of.

The Forever One Sparkle: What Reviewers Rave About

Without a doubt, the most frequently praised aspect of Forever One Moissanite in customer reviews is its incredible sparkle. Wearers consistently describe it as exceptionally brilliant and eye-catching. Many compare it favorably to diamond, often noting that Moissanite exhibits even more “fire” – the dazzling flashes of rainbow color. This intense spectral light is a signature characteristic of Moissanite, stemming from its higher dispersion rate than diamond.

Customers often express sheer delight with how their rings, pendants, or earrings catch the light. Phrases like, “It’s absolutely stunning, I catch myself staring at it all the time!” or “The sparkle is insane, like a tiny disco ball!” are common refrains.

This vibrant sparkle is particularly noticeable under varied lighting conditions, from indoor overhead lights to outdoor sunlight. While some gem enthusiasts prefer the more balanced white brilliance and subtle fire of a diamond, those drawn to a dynamic, colorful light show often find Forever One’s sparkle genuinely captivating.

Value for Money: Customer Perspectives

A significant factor driving interest in Forever One Moissanite collection is its price point relative to its appearance and durability. Customers consistently highlight the exceptional value proposition it offers compared to natural diamonds. Many feel they were able to acquire a larger, higher-quality-looking stone than would have been possible with their budget for a diamond.

Reviewers often share sentiments like, “I got the look I wanted for a fraction of the cost of a diamond, it feels like such a smart decision,” or “We could afford a much bigger and sparklier stone with Moissanite than we ever could with a diamond, and honestly, no one can tell the difference unless we tell them.”

While Forever One isn’t the cheapest Moissanite available on the market (other brands may offer lower prices), many customers feel the quality assurance and the specific colorless grading from Charles & Colvard justify the cost, stating,

“Forever One isn’t the cheapest Moissanite, but the quality difference was worth it for me; it truly looks premium.”

The consensus among these buyers is that Forever One provides a high-quality, beautiful gem without the significant financial outlay associated with a diamond of similar visual impact.

Durability in Real Life

Based on customer feedback, Forever One Moissanite holds up exceptionally well to daily wear. Its high Mohs hardness rating of 9.25 translates into real-world durability that satisfies wearers. Reviews rarely mention scratching or chipping under normal circumstances.

Customers often report wearing their rings or other pieces every day without issue. Comments like, “I wear my ring every day and it still looks perfect, no scratches after two years,” or “I was worried about daily wear, but it holds up just like my diamond jewelry; I haven’t babied it at all,” are typical.

While no gemstone is truly indestructible under extreme force, Moissanite’s resilience is a major point of customer satisfaction, reassuring buyers that their investment is not only beautiful but also practical for long-term wear. Its resistance to becoming cloudy or dull over time, unlike some diamond simulants, is also frequently noted positively.

Customer Service & Warranty Feedback

Experiences with Charles & Colvard’s customer service and warranty vary, as is common with any large retailer, but many customers report positive interactions. The company offers a limited lifetime warranty which covers the stone’s optical properties (brilliance and fire) and inherent physical properties.

Reviewers who have utilized the warranty or contacted customer service often share positive outcomes, particularly regarding issues with manufacturing defects or questions about their stone. However, like any company, there are occasional reports of less satisfactory experiences, though these appear less frequent than positive accounts.

Overall, the availability of a dedicated warranty and the reputation of Charles & Colvard for standing behind their premium product contributes to customer confidence. My dedicated review of Charles & Colvard provides a more detailed look at their service aspects.

Color: Is it Truly Colorless?

Charles & Colvard markets Forever One as their answer to colorless moissanite (D-E-F grade equivalent). Based on customer reviews, for the vast majority of wearers, this claim holds true. Most describe their Forever One stones as appearing completely colorless or icy white in almost all lighting conditions.

However, a nuanced point sometimes mentioned by a small number of reviewers is that in very specific warm or yellow lighting conditions, particularly older artificial lights, they thought they might perceive a faint hint of warmth or color.

This is not a widespread criticism and seems highly dependent on subjective perception and lighting environment. The overwhelming consensus from customer feedback is that Forever One successfully achieves a colorless or near-colorless look that satisfies those seeking a diamond-like appearance without any yellow or gray undertones common in older moissanite.

Common Criticisms and Things to Note

While overwhelmingly positive, customer reviews do highlight a few aspects to be aware of when choosing Forever One. The most prominent is the intensity of the fire or rainbow sparkle. While many adore it, some customers accustomed to diamonds find Moissanite’s higher dispersion produces too much rainbow flash, preferring the more balanced sparkle of a diamond.

This is a matter of personal preference and not a flaw, but it’s a noticeable difference frequently discussed.

Another point, less common now with the high quality of Forever One, but occasionally mentioned in older reviews, relates to specific lighting conditions potentially revealing a subtle color nuance, as discussed above.

Finally, while durable, Moissanite is not as hard as diamond, meaning a diamond can scratch a Moissanite stone. While unlikely in daily wear against other jewelry, it’s a technical point worth noting. Despite these minor points, the overall sentiment from customer feedback paints a very positive picture of Forever One Moissanite as a beautiful, durable, and high-value gemstone.

Synthesized Customer Feedback	Common Observations
Pros	1. Exceptional brilliance and sparkle, often described as having intense “fire” or rainbow flashes. 2. Excellent value for money compared to diamonds of similar size and appearance. 3. High durability (Mohs 9.25), very resistant to scratching and suitable for daily wear. 4. Appears truly colorless or icy white to most people in most lighting conditions. 5. Customers are often thrilled with the size and quality they could afford. 6. Generally positive experiences with durability over time.
Cons (Less Frequent)	1. The intense rainbow sparkle can be “too much fire” for some who prefer a diamond’s sparkle. 2. A very small number of reviewers perceive a faint color nuance in specific lighting. 3. While durable, it can still be scratched by a diamond.

Forever One Moissanite vs. Diamond: A Buyer’s Decision

For many considering a Forever One Moissanite, the comparison to diamond is central to their decision-making process. While both are stunning, transparent gemstones used prominently in jewelry, they are fundamentally different materials with distinct properties that translate into visible and practical differences a buyer should consider.

Understanding these points is key to choosing the stone that best aligns with your preferences, values, and budget.

Visual Differences in Sparkle and Light

The most talked-about difference between Forever One Moissanite and diamond lies in their sparkle. Both gems are incredibly brilliant, reflecting a high amount of white light back to the eye. However, Moissanite has a significantly higher dispersion rate than diamond.

This means Moissanite is more effective at splitting white light into its spectral colors, producing more intense and numerous “rainbow flashes,” often referred to as “fire.” Diamonds also exhibit fire, but it’s typically less pronounced and balanced with broader flashes of white light (brilliance) and scintillation (sparkle from movement).

As synthesized from customer reviews, many are drawn to Moissanite precisely because of this heightened fire, describing it as a vibrant, lively sparkle. Others, particularly those accustomed to the look of diamonds, might perceive Moissanite’s intense rainbow flashes as being “too much fire” or even giving it a slightly artificial or “disco ball” effect in certain bright lighting conditions.

Moissanite is also doubly refractive, a property not found in diamond, although this is usually only detectable with magnification and expert tools. The visual difference in how they handle light is perhaps the most apparent distinction to the naked eye.

The Practical Reality of Cost

For most buyers, the most significant difference between Forever One Moissanite and diamond comes down to cost. Moissanite is considerably less expensive than diamond, often by a factor of 10 or more for stones of comparable size and perceived quality (color, clarity). This allows buyers to purchase a much larger or higher-quality (in terms of the 4 Cs) Moissanite stone for the same budget they would spend on a diamond.

This practical reality of cost is a major driver for customers choosing Moissanite. As reflected in customer reviews, the ability to acquire a beautiful, durable, and visually striking gemstone at a fraction of the price of a diamond is a compelling advantage.

While the price of Forever One Moissanite scales with size, it does so much less steeply than the exponential price increase seen with larger diamonds due to their rarity.

Rarity, Tradition, and Perception

Diamonds are natural minerals formed over millions of years deep within the Earth, making large, high-quality stones inherently rare. Moissanite, while naturally occurring, is so scarce that virtually all jewelry-quality stones are lab-grown. This fundamental difference in origin and rarity contributes significantly to their value and perception.

Diamonds carry centuries of tradition and cultural significance, particularly in the context of engagement rings. For some, the symbolism of a natural diamond, its historical journey, and its association with eternal love rooted in natural rarity, are irreplaceable.

Moissanite, being a newer player in the jewelry market (as a lab-grown gem), lacks this long-standing tradition. While its acceptance is growing rapidly, there can still be social perceptions or expectations tied to choosing a diamond, which some buyers weigh in their decision.

However, a growing number of consumers prioritize value, modern technology, and affordability over traditional rarity and perception.

How Experts Tell Them Apart

While difficult for the untrained eye, gemologists can readily distinguish between Forever One Moissanite and diamond using standard gemological tools. Differences in refractive index, dispersion, and the presence of double refraction (visible under magnification) are key indicators.

Diamond testers that measure electrical or thermal conductivity can often differentiate them as well, as their thermal and electrical properties differ. Reputable jewelers and appraisers are equipped to identify Moissanite accurately.

Which Stone Is Right For Your Priorities?

Ultimately, the choice between a Forever One Moissanite and a diamond for an engagement ring, anniversary gift, or other significant jewelry piece is a personal one based on individual priorities.

If factors like historical tradition, natural rarity, and the specific balance of white brilliance and subtle fire are paramount, and budget allows, a diamond may be the preferred choice.

However, if achieving maximum sparkle, exceptional durability, and significant size for your budget are the main goals, and you are comfortable with a lab-grown gem that is visually distinct in its fire and lacks the deep historical tradition of natural diamonds, then Forever One Moissanite presents a highly compelling and value-driven alternative.

The customer reviews we’ve synthesized strongly suggest that for many, Forever One successfully meets the desire for a brilliant, durable, and beautiful gemstone at a much more accessible price point than a diamond.

Here is a summary comparing key aspects:

Feature	Forever One Moissanite	Diamond
Origin	Lab-grown (Natural extremely rare)	Natural (Formed in Earth) or Lab-grown
Composition	Silicon Carbide (SiC)	Carbon (C)
Mohs Hardness	9.25 (Excellent)	10 (Hardest Natural Mineral)
Sparkle	Very high brilliance & high fire (strong rainbow flashes)	High brilliance & moderate fire (balanced sparkle)
Refraction	Double Refractive	Single Refractive
Cost (Relative)	Significantly Lower (Often 10x+ less for similar size)	Significantly Higher (Price increases exponentially)
Rarity	Not rare (Lab-grown)	Natural diamonds are rare (especially large, high quality)
Tradition/Perception	Newer, growing acceptance	Deep historical tradition, widely accepted
Identification	Distinguishable by gemological tools & testers	Distinguishable by gemological tools & testers
Resale Value	Typically Low	Generally Higher (varies greatly by quality & market)
Customer View	High value, intense sparkle, durable alternative	Traditional, prestigious, classic sparkle

The choice ultimately comes down to what qualities you value most in your jewelry and which stone’s story and characteristics resonate most deeply with you.

Caring for Your Forever One Moissanite Jewelry

One of the practical benefits of choosing Forever One Moissanite is its exceptional durability, which translates directly into relatively easy care and maintenance. With a Mohs hardness of 9.25, Moissanite is highly resistant to scratching and abrasion from daily wear, ensuring its brilliance lasts.

However, like any precious jewelry, a little routine care goes a long way in keeping it looking its absolute best.

Routine Cleaning at Home

Keeping your Forever One Moissanite sparkling is simple. The most effective and recommended method for regular cleaning is using warm water and a few drops of mild dish soap. Soak your jewelry for a few minutes, then gently brush the stone and setting with a soft-bristled brush, like a clean toothbrush, to dislodge any dirt, oils, or residue.

Rinse thoroughly under warm water and dry with a soft, lint-free cloth. This simple routine will remove the build-up that can dull the intense fire and brilliance of your Moissanite.

Using an Ultrasonic Cleaner

Thanks to its high hardness and stability, Forever One Moissanite is generally safe for cleaning in a home ultrasonic cleaner. These devices use high-frequency sound waves to agitate a liquid solution, effectively loosening dirt and grime from intricate settings that brushing might miss.

If you own an ultrasonic cleaner, it can be a convenient option for your Moissanite jewelry. For guidance on choosing the right products, our Best Moissanite Cleaner Guide offers helpful tips.

Protecting Your Moissanite

While very durable, it’s still wise to take simple precautions. Avoid exposing your Moissanite jewelry to harsh chemicals, such as strong cleaning agents or bleach, as these can potentially damage the metal setting over time.

You might also wonder, can you clean moissanite with alcohol ? While short-term use of isopropyl alcohol is generally considered safe for the stone itself, it’s always best to stick to mild soap and water for routine cleaning to protect the metal and any intricate setting details.

As with any fine jewelry, periodic professional cleaning and inspection are recommended. A jeweler can ensure your stone is secure in its setting and give it a thorough clean. Finally, store your Moissanite jewelry separately from other pieces to prevent them from getting scratched by harder gems (like diamonds) or scratching softer stones.

By following these simple care tips, your Forever One Moissanite will maintain its breathtaking sparkle for decades to come.

Frequently Asked Questions About Forever One Moissanite

It’s natural to have questions when considering a gemstone like Forever One Moissanite. Based on common inquiries and the feedback we’ve synthesized from customers, here are some direct answers to frequently asked questions:

Conclusion: Is Forever One Moissanite the Right Choice For Your Journey?

As we’ve explored what real customers are saying, a clear picture of Forever One Moissanite emerges. It’s a gemstone widely celebrated for its stunning, intense sparkle and impressive durability, proving to be an excellent choice for everyday wear.

Wearers consistently highlight the remarkable value it offers, providing a beautiful, high-performance gem at a price point significantly more accessible than that of a diamond. While it has its own distinct visual characteristics, particularly its vibrant fire, the overwhelming sentiment from customer feedback suggests that for many seeking a diamond alternative, Forever One Moissanite delivers on its promise of beauty and resilience.

Ultimately, the decision comes down to your personal priorities, your budget, and the unique qualities you value most in a gemstone for your own jewelry journey. Choosing the right gem is about finding the perfect fit for you.